SDV Insights

Two More Insureds Ante Up: Oklahoma Tribes Step Up to the Business Interruption Table


On Tuesday, March 24, 2020, the Chickasaw and Choctaw Nations (the “Nations”), located in Oklahoma, filed separate business interruption coverage lawsuits against their collective group of insurers who allegedly issued “all risk” policies to both Nations. These actions, styled Chickasaw Nation Dept. of Commerce v. Lexington Insurance Company, et. al.1 and Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma v. Lexington Insurance Company, et. al.,2 allege that the insureds own and operate property associated with multiple commercial businesses and services within Oklahoma. Although not alleged in the pleadings, Chickasaw Nation owns and operates more than 15 casinos and other gambling facilities, while Choctaw Nation appears to own and operate at least seven.

In many ways, these two cases will be very similar to others filed to date, including the cases filed by New Orleans’ Oceana Grill and California’s The French Laundry restaurants. The Nations have alleged that the USA as a whole was infected by COVID-19 and that, as a result, their property “sustained direct physical loss or damage and will continue to sustain direct physical loss or damage covered by the policies, including but not limited to business interruption, extra expense, interruption by civil authority, limitations on ingress and egress, and expenses to reduce loss.” It is not clear whether the Nations’ policies have virus exclusions or civil authority coverage provisions.

Aside from the similarities, these cases will also add an additional interesting facet to the coverage discussion concerning COVID-19-related exposures. Business interruption coverage provisions are typically written with some calculation of lost profits or lost revenue. Casinos and other facilities in the gambling industry involve many different streams of income aside from just gambling, often incorporating restaurants, spas, hotels, and family-friendly attractions. These unique characteristics will make business interruption claims like those filed by the Chickasaw and Choctaw Nations especially complex. Other than the issues these cases share with many other Coronavirus-derived losses, there will be many additional opportunities for insurers to challenge the insureds over various aspects of their claims. We anticipate these are just the first of many similar cases filed by insureds in the casino industry, as those companies are currently being exposed to monumental losses resulting from current shutdowns and will continue to be exposed to losses, due to the public’s lingering fear over infection in crowded public spaces.

For more information contact William S. Bennett at wsb@sdvlaw.com or 951-365-3148.

___________________________________________________________________

1Case No. CV-20-3S, District Court of the Pontotoc County, State of Oklahoma.
2
Case No. CV-20-42, District Court of the Bryan County, State of Oklahoma. In both cases, the defendants are fifteen insurers, including multiple Lloyd’s of London syndicates and many domestic carriers, such as XL, Evanston and Hallmark, among others.


Click on this link to view the article in pdf format






CONTACT US

The email you are sending does not create an attorney-client relationship with SDV. We do not agree to representation until we have performed a check for conflicts of interest and expressly agree to provide services in a particular matter via an engagement letter. The information submitted to us via this website will NOT be treated as confidential or privileged as a lawyer/client communication and our receipt of this information does not prevent us from representing a client related to the subject of your inquiry.

Northeast

35 Nutmeg Drive
Trumbull, CT 06611

203.287.2100

Southeast

851 5th Avenue N
Naples, FL 34102

239.316.7244

West Coast

Two BetterWorld Circle
Temecula, CA 92590

951.365.3145


SDV is based in Connecticut, conveniently located between New York City and Boston, with regional offices in Florida and California to better serve our clients. We're ready to answer your questions and eager to assist you in developing solutions.