SDV Insights

South Dakota Supreme Court Holds That Faulty Workmanship Constitutes an "Occurrence"


If you have a commercial general liability policy that is subject to South Dakota law, damages resulting from faulty workmanship constitute an “occurrence” under your policy.  In a pro-policyholder decision out of South Dakota, the court in Owners Ins. Co. v. Tibke Construction, Inc. held that damages caused by a subcontractor’s failure to test soil compaction before constructing a home constituted an “occurrence” under a commercial general liability policy.  This decision is yet another example of the Supreme Court of South Dakota holding that faulty workmanship constitutes an “occurrence” under a commercial general liability policy, and should be beneficial for policyholders in similar situations.

The South Dakota Supreme Court recently determined that damage resulting from a subcontractor’s failure to test soil compaction before constructing a home constituted an “accident” and was therefore an “occurrence” under a commercial general liability (CGL) policy.

In Owners Ins. Co. v. Tibke Construction, Inc.,1 the homeowners hired Tibke Construction, Inc. to build a new house, and Tibke Construction hired subcontractor Jerry’s Excavating to perform excavation work. The homeowners contended that Jerry’s Excavating failed to do soil compaction testing before commencing construction, which resulted in the home being built on highly expansive soils, leading to damage including excessive settlement, cracking and structural unsoundness.

The homeowners sued Tibke Construction and Jerry’s Excavating for the damages to their home. Tibke Construction tendered a claim for defense and indemnity to its CGL insurer, Owners Insurance Company (Owners), which disputed coverage but agreed to defend Tibke Construction under a reservation of rights.

Owners then filed a declaratory judgment action seeking a determination that the CGL policy did not provide coverage for Tibke Construction against the homeowners’ allegations. The policy covered property damage caused by an “occurrence,” which was defi ned as an accident. Owners argued that a claim arising from incorrectly performed work, such as failure to test the soil, does not constitute an accident because a CGL policy is not meant to cover faulty workmanship. Using lack of fortuity as a basis for this argument, Owners noted that the loss arose “from the defendants’ intentional choice not to conduct soil testing and their deliberate decision to construct the house on that soil.”

The South Dakota Supreme Court rejected Owners’ argument, stating that faulty workmanship can cause unexpected and fortuitous losses or damage, which constitutes an “occurrence” because the result is neither expected nor intended by the insured. In this case, “the failure to test the soil was not an intentional or deliberate action but an unplanned omission, which caused an unexpected result.”

This pro-policyholder decision should have a positive impact for policyholders seeking coverage for damages caused by defective construction in South Dakota. To see how defective construction is treated in your jurisdiction, see our survey: Defective Construction as an “Occurrence.”

For more information about this case contact Samantha Martino at smm@sdvlaw.com. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ 

1 2017 S.D. 51 (2017).

Click on this link to view the article in pdf format






CONTACT US

The email you are sending does not create an attorney-client relationship with SDV. We do not agree to representation until we have performed a check for conflicts of interest and expressly agree to provide services in a particular matter via an engagement letter. The information submitted to us via this website will NOT be treated as confidential or privileged as a lawyer/client communication and our receipt of this information does not prevent us from representing a client related to the subject of your inquiry.

Northeast

35 Nutmeg Drive
Trumbull, CT 06611

203.287.2100

Southeast

851 5th Avenue N
Naples, FL 34102

239.316.7244

West Coast

Two BetterWorld Circle
Temecula, CA 92590

951.365.3145


SDV is based in Connecticut, conveniently located between New York City and Boston, with regional offices in Florida and California to better serve our clients. We're ready to answer your questions and eager to assist you in developing solutions.